The Face Beneath the Masks

A Meditation on Sincerity, Freedom, and the Daily Refusal to Lie

Dino’s Homily and Poetry Site

---

I’ve carried masks most of my life. Some fit so well I forgot they weren’t skin. Others pinched at the edges, uncomfortable but necessary for a time. A mask to sit across from generals and senators. A mask to soften myself for a grieving family. A mask to smile through moments when my chest felt like it might crack open. They were useful—until they weren’t.

The trouble with masks is that if you wear them long enough, you start to lose the memory of your own face.

Integrity, at least as I’ve come to know it, is remembering. Remembering that my words, my actions, and the person I am when no one’s watching should be one and the same. Not identical in detail—life calls for adjustments, for tact, for mercy—but one in essence. One thread running through it all.

That sounds noble. It isn’t. It’s messy, costly, and sometimes lonely. But the alternative—living split between versions of yourself—is far worse.

Facing What Masks Hide

I once heard a line from Baldwin that cut straight through me: nothing can be changed until it’s faced. That’s the kind of truth that doesn’t leave you alone. I think of it whenever I’m tempted to put on a mask for convenience. Because masks are nothing but avoidance stitched into costume. They hide what we’re too afraid to face, and in hiding, they change nothing.

On the other side of the world, centuries earlier, Confucius spoke about sincerity as the root of character. Not performance, not polish, but sincerity. To him, sincerity wasn’t an accessory you put on to look respectable. It was the bedrock under your feet. If you lost it, the whole structure of your life swayed in the wind.

Baldwin gives me the courage to face what I’d rather avoid. Confucius gives me the reminder that sincerity isn’t decoration—it’s foundation. And when I put those two together, I hear one simple call: live without masks.

The Pressure of Public Life

But here’s the catch. Public life almost requires them. Anyone who’s spent time in boardrooms or battlefields knows the rules. You say one thing for effect and another for truth. You temper your language to keep your seat at the table. You downplay your grief, your anger, your dissent. The mask isn’t an accident—it’s the ticket for admission.

I’ve worn those tickets. They worked. And every time, I felt myself chip away a little bit. The applause might come, but when the room empties, you’re left with the echo of your own compromise.

That echo follows you home. It whispers in the private hours when you replay the day. That’s where the private masks live—the ones no one else sees but that gnaw just the same. Excuses dressed as wisdom. Rationalizations dressed as compassion. “I didn’t tell the truth because it would’ve hurt them.” “I kept quiet because peace matters more than honesty.” They sound noble until you sit with them long enough. Then they sound like fear.

Montaigne, centuries ago, said that the greatest thing in the world is to know how to belong to yourself. Masks cheat us of that belonging. They make us outsiders in our own lives.

The Three-Strand Braid

I’ve tried to make sense of this by thinking of integrity as a braid. Three strands woven together: words, deeds, and soul. If even one unravels, the cord weakens.

Words are the easiest to betray. We toss them around for effect, use them to flatter, sharpen them into weapons. But words, once spoken, leave a trace. They shape the world around us, and they shape us too. If I say something I can’t stand by later, I’ve already started to split.

Deeds are trickier. They don’t come with captions. I’ve had to ask myself: if someone saw the whole of my action—not the part I present, but the intention, the compromise, the corner I cut—would I defend it without shame? If the answer is no, then it’s not integrity.

And then there’s the soul. The part of us that knows when we’re living a double life, even if nobody else notices. The soul feels the dissonance first. It grows restless, uneasy. That unease is often the first sign that something in the braid is slipping.

When all three are aligned, there’s a deep quiet. Not triumph, not victory, just the peace of being one person instead of a fractured cast of characters.

The Cost of Wholeness

Of course, living this way costs something. You’ll lose friends who preferred the mask. You’ll be passed over for opportunities that reward compliance. You’ll stand in rooms where people look at you like you’ve broken some unspoken rule. I’ve felt all of that.

But the alternative costs more. Every mask steals something small until you look in the mirror and can’t remember who you are. I’ve watched men lose themselves that way—not from one grand betrayal but from a thousand small evasions that accumulated into ruin.

Gramsci once wrote from prison that telling the truth is always revolutionary. He wasn’t talking about slogans or grand speeches, but about the stubborn refusal to pretend. Integrity may not win you applause, but it makes you ungovernable by lies.

It helps me to think of integrity as freedom. Without masks, I don’t have to rehearse my lines. I don’t have to worry which version of me someone has met. I don’t have to guard against exposure. I can simply be. That freedom doesn’t make life easier, but it makes it livable.

A Chorus of Lesser Lights

Zhuangzi, the Daoist sage, once told a story of a man who dreamed he was a butterfly, then woke unsure which was real. His point was simple: the masks we cling to are often just more dreams. The truer self is freer, lighter, closer to the butterfly than to the armor.

Jane Addams, working in the crowded streets of Chicago, believed integrity wasn’t only personal but social. A community is sick, she said, when people live two lives—one private and one public. She lived her whole career trying to close that gap.

George Eliot wrote that the growing good of the world depends partly on unhistoric acts—on people who lived faithfully a private life, who never wore masks for applause. That rings truer to me with every passing year.

And Bashō, in his spare way, taught that attention to one small, ordinary truth could hold the whole world. He turned integrity into a haiku—brevity as honesty, simplicity as wholeness.

All of them, in their different accents, say the same thing: wholeness matters more than polish.

Integrity as Resistance

I think often of Václav Havel’s phrase “living in truth.” He wrote it in a time when masks were mandatory and lies were law. And yet he insisted that even one person refusing to pretend could puncture the whole theater. That idea comforts me. Because integrity isn’t only about saving my own skin. It keeps alive the possibility of something larger—freedom for a community, for a nation. If enough of us live without masks, the charade collapses.

But it starts small. It starts with admitting you forgot instead of making an excuse. Owning that you were wrong instead of doubling down. Telling a friend you disagree instead of nodding along. Small truths prepare you for larger ones. Integrity is not built in heroic gestures, but in the daily refusal to lie.

The Quiet Work

The more I sit with this, the more I realize integrity isn’t about being flawless. It’s about being consistent enough to be trusted. About letting the cracks show rather than painting over them. About choosing truth in pieces so small they look insignificant—until they add up to a life that feels like it belongs to you.

I return, again and again, to Baldwin’s reminder that change begins with facing what is. And to Confucius’s reminder that sincerity is the foundation, not the accessory. And around those two pillars, I hear the chorus of other voices—Eliot, Bashō, Zhuangzi, Montaigne, Gramsci, Addams—telling me in a hundred ways that the soul wants to be whole, not divided.

And I believe them.

Living Without Fear

The work of being whole isn’t glamorous. It doesn’t come with medals or applause. It comes in the quiet moment when you speak a truth that costs you something. When you admit a failure instead of covering it. When you align word, deed, and soul so that no matter who’s in the room—or whether anyone is at all—you are the same person.

And if I may laugh at myself a little—I’ve often said I don’t follow in the steps of the faithful, that reason is my compass. Yet even I have to admit that scripture occasionally slips in a line so solid you can lean on it: “You shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.” That’s from the Gospel of John, chapter 8, verse 32. I can roll my eyes at chapter-and-verse debates, but the sentence itself? That one I’ll keep. It reminds me that freedom isn’t just political or personal—it’s moral. You can’t be free if you’re still hiding behind masks.

So I don’t quote scripture to wear the mask of faith or to collect readers who wish I’d preach. I do it to show that wisdom is wherever you find it, and to remind myself not to take even my own unbelief too seriously.

That’s what it means to live without masks. And when you can do that, you don’t just reclaim your own face. You step into a kind of freedom no one can take from you.

Light Against Empire - The Podcast Episodes

Further Reading: