Life After Leaving Church (6)

The Authority You Carry

This essay is part of Life After Leaving Church, a series focused on practical ways to rebuild meaning, structure, and care after stepping away from organized religion.

Leaving church is loud.

There are conversations you rehearse in the shower. Explanations you revise mid sentence. Nights when your mind refuses to settle because you’re trying to be certain you’re not making a mistake.

There is the moment you realize you’re not going back.

And then there is the strange quiet that follows.

Living afterward is different.

Living afterward is quiet.

At first, that quiet can feel like exposure. As if something that once covered you has been removed. A structure. A rhythm. A shared vocabulary that told you who you were and how you were doing.

You may have wondered whether you were drifting.

But over time something steadier begins to take shape.

You are still here.

Still thinking.
Still loving.
Still wrestling with what is right.

The leaving did not erase you.

It uncovered you.

---

The Myth of Spiritual Supervision

Many of us were formed inside a story that assumed supervision.

Someone was watching.
Someone was evaluating.
Someone was keeping score.

Even when the theology softened, the reflex often remained. We absorbed the sense that goodness required oversight. That moral seriousness required external authority. That we were safest when someone else confirmed we were acceptable.

There is wisdom in accountability. Community matters. Tradition can steady us.

But something subtle can happen in highly supervised spiritual systems.

We begin to hand over our conscience.

We ask not simply, “Is this honest?” but “Will this pass?”
We ask not simply, “Is this loving?” but “Is this permitted?”

And when you leave, that supervision disappears.

No one is grading your soul anymore.

At first that can feel like vertigo.

Then something else begins to surface.

Relief.

And with it, responsibility.

---

The Return of Conscience

When external monitoring fades, conscience does not vanish with it.

It becomes more distinct.

Surveillance morality says: behave.

Conscience says: be honest.

Surveillance morality worries about appearance.

Conscience asks about alignment.

Without the constant sense of being watched, your moral life may begin to simplify. Not because everything is easy. But because the questions change.

Not, “What would they think?”
But, “What do I know is true?”

Not, “How do I avoid being wrong?”
But, “How do I remain decent?”

This is moral adulthood.

It is not rebellion.
It is not cynicism.
It is not abandoning the good that shaped you.

It is standing without a referee.

You may begin to notice that the voice you once attributed entirely to authority was, in part, your own developing wisdom.

You were listening all along.

---

Integration Instead of Reaction

There is a season after leaving when everything feels charged.

You correct old language.
You tense at familiar phrases.
You define yourself by what you no longer believe.

That season makes sense. You are sorting through threads that ran through your whole life. You are protecting yourself from slipping back into patterns that once confined you.

But living in reaction is exhausting.

Integration feels different.

Integration is quieter.

You no longer tense at every reference. You do not need to win every argument in your head. You are not compelled to dismantle every doctrine at the dinner table.

You choose your ground.

You keep what is honest. You release what is not. You are not defined by the building you left.

That is not indifference.

It is steadiness.

You are no longer reacting to the past.

You are living in the present.

---

What Stayed

This may be the most important discovery.

So much stayed.

Your compassion stayed.
Your reverence for mystery stayed.
Your moral seriousness stayed.
Your hunger for meaning stayed.
Your desire to love well stayed.

Those things were never owned by an institution.

They may have been nurtured there. Given language there. Framed by ritual there.

But they were always yours.

Leaving church did not erase your capacity for awe. It did not erase your longing for goodness. It did not erase your instinct to care for others.

If anything, it made them clearer.

Without performance.
Without pressure.
Without constant evaluation.

What was real did not collapse when the structure did.

It remained.

And it grew.

---

Practice: Living With the Authority You Carry

This week, make one decision without imagining anyone judging it. Not former pastors. Not family. Not a younger version of yourself.

Ask only: Is this honest?

Tell the truth once where you might previously have softened it to stay agreeable.

Do something generous that no one will know about. No witness. No approval. Just quiet goodness.

Sit with one difficult moral question without rushing to hand it to someone else. Let your own conscience work. Resist the urge to search for a ready made conclusion.

Then notice.

Notice that you are not adrift.

Notice that your inner life is capable of steadiness.

---

A Quiet Close

You left.

You grieved.

You rebuilt.

Now you live.

There may not be a weekly benediction over your choices. There may not be a shared confession or a closing hymn.

But there is something steady.

There is the authority you carry.

It is not loud. It does not demand applause. It does not need constant validation.

It is the quiet recognition that you are responsible for your life.

Not supervised.

Not graded.

Responsible.

That is not loneliness.

It is adulthood.

And you are already living it.

---

Please Support the Work

Light Against Empire is free for all. If my words have value to you and you’re in a position to help, you can chip in with a monthly or yearly donation. Your support keeps the writing alive, the lights on, and the fire burning.

---

Further Reading: